Merit Pay Linked to Test Scores?
On July 2, Education Secretary Arne Duncan spoke to members of the NEA at their national convention in San Diego exhorting them to stop fighting the idea of student achievement as a consideration for teacher pay. While he did say that test scores should never be the driving force behind teacher compensation, he also stated, “But to remove student achievement entirely from evaluation is illogical and indefensible,”
Well, the dreaded words are being spoken! Every time I hear the concept of merit pay linked in any way to state testing results it frightens me! Let me add that most of my students’ test results over the last several years have been well above passing, but I fundamentally disagree with test scores being used as the litmus test to judge teacher quality. Teachers understand the wide variety of factors that affect test results: parent involvement or lack of; parent concern or apathy for their child’s test results; the student population which covers everything from discipline problems, the number of students who are gifted, SPED, ADHD, on 504 plans, etc.; class size; home situations; and when the tests are taken to name a few. (This year, we administered the tests in our district the week students came back from Easter break!) What about teachers who work in intercity schools with the multitude of issues they face daily? These are all factors we cannot control, but they certainly impact test results.
Is there any tangible evidence to support the assumption that student test scores determine the competency of a teacher? How do we figure in all of the extraneous factors over which teachers have no control?
There are a plethora of characteristics that make an exceptional teacher, some measurable and some not. Certainly with the myriad specimens of obtainable evidence which attest to a teacher’s merit, we need not resort to test results as evidence of anything but how we were able to rise above all of the countless issues and distractions we face in education every day and still facilitate student progress.
Take a stand and get vocal! Post some comments here and on other sites on this volatile topic. This is not the time to be complacent.
Changes in Teaching, Merit Pay for Teachers, Teacher-World's Blog, state achievement tests, teacher evaluations
As you might know –teachers keep their jobs because they learn not to speak about anything that goes on at work. If the state really knew what a teacher really has to go through to keep job. Every school has people that run it –that are not truthful and should not be in charge of anything. I can just say one thing, I agree with everything written on this website. I just don’t understand why the people making these decisions won’t make changes to benifit teachers. In the educational field, teachers are the only people that endure everything in the classroom. The other professionals don’t really do a thing, they just get paid for it.